|
|

By
DANIEL STURM
Mary Pollock said that at the age of 14 she’d been very curious
about sex. But it was difficult for her to gain access to interesting
books on the subject, such as D. H. Lawrence’s “Lady Chatterley’s
Lover.”

Bishop
T.D. Turner Sr. of the Jesus Non-Denominational Church adds a video
to a fire full of Harry Potter books and “other witchcraft
items” in Greenville, Mich., last August, Greenville is about
75 miles northwest of Lansing. |
As late as 1960, Lawrence’s novel was the object of several obscenity
trials due to its explicit treatment of sexuality. The story revolved
around an adulterous affair between a sexually unfulfilled upper-class
married woman and the gamekeeper working on her estate.
Pollock, who is today the vice president of the American Civil Liberties
Union in Lansing, said her parents wouldn’t give her permission
to read the novel, though she’d spotted it on their bookshelf.
This made her all the more curious. “Why is it the adults don’t
want me to read it?” she wondered.
Looking older than her years, Pollock was eventually able to check the
novel out from the adult section of the library, and still remembers:
“It had thrilling content.”
On
Friday, Sept. 26, the ACLU vice president will join about 30 other local
community members and writers to read from their favorite banned books
at Way Station Books and Stuff, in downtown Lansing. Pollock’s
choice will be “Lady Chatterley’s Lover,” of course.
The event was inspired by the American Library Association’s Banned
Books Week, an annual celebration of the freedom to read, which reminds
Americans not to take this precious democratic freedom for granted.
Banned
Books Week
Community leaders, including journalists, elected officials
and civil rights lawyers, will read from books as varied as
“Lord of the Flies” and “Lady Chatterly’s
Lover.” Local folk singer Medicine Crow (Michael Iott)
will perform selections of banned songs and at 12:30 p.m. there
will be a group performance of “Louie Louie” using
the original words. 11:30 to 1:30 p.m., Way Station Books, 223
S. Washington Sq., Lansing. (517) 853-1336.
|
Ironically, novels that are renown for their masterful writing style
and lyricism, have been at top of the U.S. banned books list.
James Joyce’s “Ulysses,” which was selected by Modern
Library as the best novel of the 20th century, was seized by U.S postal
authorities from 1918 until 1933 and barred from the country as obscene
literature for 15 years. The ban’s removal in 1933 came only after
Joyce’s advocates fought a legal battle for the right to publish
the book.
Aristophanes’ “Lysistrata,” Chaucer’s “Canterbury
Tales,” Boccaccio’s “Decameron,” Defoe’s
“Moll Flanders” and several editions of “The Arabian
Nights” were all banned for decades from delivery to the United
States under the Comstock Law of 1873. Officially known as the Federal
Anti-Obscenity Act, the law banned the delivery of “lewd,”
“indecent,” “filthy,” and “obscene”
materials through the U.S. mail.
In today’s world, where even kids are used to reading about sex
and seeing it in the movies, one might think the issue of banning books
is no longer politically relevant.
Banned/Challenged
Books in Michigan 2002-2003
Source: American Library Association, Office for Intellectual
Freedom 2003
Book title
Grounds for Challenge
2002
Finding My Voice, by Marie G. Lee
Offensive language
The
Giver, by Lois Lowry
Unsuited to age group
I
Had Seen Castles, by Cynthia Rylant
Unknown
Harry
Potter Series, by J.K. Rowling
Occult/Satanism
Catcher
in the Rye, by J.D. Salinger
Offensive language
And
Then There Was Non, by Agatha Christie
Violence
Batman:
The Ultimate Guide to the Dark Knight, by Scott Beatty
Sexuallyexplicit/Unsuited to age group
Stance
Magazine Unsuited for young patrons
Sexually explicit
Wiccan
Magick for Beginners, by Lady Sabrina
Religious viewpoint/Occult/satanism
Of
Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck
Offensive language/Racism
The
Drug Awareness Library, by Ruth Chier
Drugs
2003
Harry Potter Series, by J.K. Rowling
Religious viewpoint/Unsuited to age group
Slaughterhouse
Five, by Kurt Vonnegut Insensitivity/sexually explicit/offensive
language/political viewpoint/unsuited to age group
Guiness
World Records 2002
Unsuited to age
Sexy
Beast, with Ben Kingsley (Film) Homosexuality/nudity/sexually
explicit/anti-
family/offensive language/violence
Revolting
Rhymes, by Roald Dahl
Offensive language
Pinky
and Rex and the Bully, by James Howe
Homosexuality
The
Dilbert Future: Thriving on Stupidity in the 21st Century,
by Scott Adams
Sexually explicit
|
But
the library association’s Office for Intellectual Freedom in Chicago
has records of more than 7,000 books challenged since 1990, including
515 in 2002. And the organization estimates that less than one-quarter
of all attempts to remove books from school curricula or library shelves
are reported. A formal “challenge” to a piece of literature
is defined as a written complaint filed with a library or school regarding
a book’s content or appropriateness. Roughly 60 percent of all
challenges are brought by parents, followed by library patrons and administrators.
In Michigan, 18 books have been challenged since 2002, according to
the Office for Intellectual Freedom. These include John Steinbeck’s
“Of Mice and Men,” J.D. Salinger’s “Catcher
in the Rye” as well as J.K. Rowling’s Harry Potter series.
The top three reasons for challenging material include “sexually
explicit” content, “offensive language” or being “unsuited
to age group.”
Beverley Becker, the assistant director of the Office for Intellectual
Freedom, said that challenges reported by individuals are kept confidential.
“That’s why we can’t disclose how many challenges
there were in Lansing,” she said.
After
discussing the issue with a sample of passionate readers, librarians
and bookstore owners, I came to the conclusion that many people believe
Lansing’s tolerance of literature is less restrictive than other
places in Michigan.
Sue Hill, the chief librarian at the Capital Area District Library in
Lansing, says the only book ever challenged during her tenure was Madonna’s
“Sex.” Hill said even though this challenge was in 1992,
before she took office, librarians still talk about how the book outraged
the community. “There were quite a few hearings, but the library
board supported having the book in the collection.”
Ironically today Madonna’s “Sex” is no longer on their
shelves - it was removed after being read so many times that the pages
became worn out.
Hill said she intends to read from Shel Silverstein’s “A
Light in the Attic” at Way Station. The novel was challenged in
1997 because it allegedly encouraged children to do forbidden things.
“For example, instead of washing dishes after supper, they would
throw them on the floor and break them,” said Hill. “But
it’s just a book with a sense of humor, it’s not to be taken
seriously.”
Sylvia
Marabate, who heads the East Lansing Public Library since 1993, said
there hasn’t been a single incident where a book was target for
a ban. “I believe the community is very highly educated. I think
they value libraries, literature, reading and diverse viewpoints.”
Two of the best-known examples of banned literature are Mark Twain’s
“The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn” and “The Adventures
of Tom Sawyer,” both books having been accused of racism, insensitivity
and offensive language. In Twain’s lifetime Huckleberry Finn was
excluded from the juvenile sections of the Brooklyn Public library and
banned from libraries in Concord, Mass.. And as recent as 1998, a parent’s
lawsuit attempting to remove Huckleberry Finn from a high school required
reading list in Tempe, Ariz., went as far as a federal appeals court.
The court’s decision affirmed Tempe High’s right to teach
the book.

Members
of the Jesus Non-Denominational Church set fire to books and posters,
compact discs and movies to take a stand against the devil. The
items burned included Shania Twain’s “The Woman in Me”
as well as movie hits “Coneheads” and “Speechless”
plus an issue of Time magazine |
Twain’s
Huckleberry Finn is the first banned book that comes to the mind of
the owner of Way Station Books and Stuff, Randy Glumm. Since opening
his store in 2002, Glumm recalls only one incident where a customer
expressed concerns. “The Tin House Quarterly Magazine did a special
literary issue devoted to sensuality and sex, and it was even a little
abrasive to me.” Glumm said he didn’t remove the magazine,
nor did he lose a customer. “I told him that I support freedom
of speech, which includes publishing works. It’s a diverse country
we live in. Everyone has the freedom to voice his or her distaste for
certain piece of literature. And we want to defend that right.”
Most public libraries and school systems require that book challenges
be formalized in writing and will not consider verbal complaints. In
2000, the American Civil Liberties Union of Texas filed a freedom of
information act request, asking all 1,184 Texas school districts to
provide information on books that had been removed from the curriculum.
Interestingly, several districts observed that after people were told
their challenges needed to be in writing, many complaints “went
away.” Of the 153 pieces of literature formally challenged in
Texas that year 65 were then banned, restricted or removed from the
curriculum.
The
following Lansing-area residents will read from banned books
11:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. Friday, Sept. 26, at Way Station Books,
223 S. Washington Sq., Lansing.
Abood, Joseph E., Attorney
Levin, Matthew, Author
Spiegel, Sam, Co-owner, Vice President, Partners
Book Distributors
Bunting, Jane Briggs, Director, MSU School
of Journalism
Butler, Kate, Professor, Cooley Law School
Clark, Anetra, Poet, Actress
Friedlis, Andre, Administrative Law Judge,
State of Michigan
Glumm, Randy, Proprietor, Way Station Books
Hamrick, Cherry, Chief Librarian, Delta Township
Library
Hill, Sue, Chief Librarian, Capital Area District
Library
Holland, Meegan, Booth Newspapers
Iott, Michael, Folk Singer
Jefferson, Marcus, Publisher, The Chronicle
Newspaper
Marabate, Sylvia, Chief Librarian, East Lansing
Public Library
Meyer, Larry, Lansing City Council Member
Nixon, Mark, Editorial Page Editor, Lansing
State Journal
Pohl, Scott, WKAR
Pollock, Mary, Vice President, ACLU
Potter, Jeff, President, out your back door
zine magazines
Preston, Dennis, Illustrator
Ramoff, Rich, Editor, Noise
Randville, Mike, Author, Lobbyist
Risper, Rina, Publisher, The New Citizen Press
Schwartz, Berl, Publisher, City Pulse
Scott, Lynne Orilla, Author
Silverman, Henry, Professor Emeritus MSU, President,
Lansing ACLU
Sosios, Alysia, News Anchor, Channel 47 TV
News
Steinberg, Mike, Author-Editor, MSU Press
Watters, Tim, Librarian, Library of Michigan
Wiener, David, City of Lansing
Wilkins, Matt, Arts and Entertainment Editor,
The Lookout
Wilson, Stuart, President, Capital Area District
Library Board
|
Most
of the time, people haven’t read the literature they are objecting
to, notes Cherry Hamrick, director of the Delta Township District Library.
“People usually say they’ve heard about a book through other
parents, or in church, where their pastor has told them to complain
about it at the local library.”
Hamrick, who was head librarian at Haslett Library for 13 years, before
recently taking her new post, said people challenge books perhaps once
a year. For instance, when a new Harry Potter is published, “somebody
wants to talk to me about whether it’s appropriate,” Hamrick
said. She responds by doing “the standard librarian thing. I say,
‘Parents need to be the monitors, and not librarians. Talk with
your child.’”
In fact, the best-selling Harry Potter series tops the list of books
most frequently challenged in 2002, including two recent challenges
in Michigan, according to the Office of Intellectual Freedom.
Early in August, The Associated Press reported that a church in Greenville,
Mich., held an old-fashioned book burning. The church’s minister
told the congregation to gather up and burn “Harry Potter books
and other witchcraft items, to let the world know that there are true
followers of Jesus Christ who will not call evil good.”
And in 1999, the superintendent of public schools of Zeeland, a town
near Holland, Mich., ordered all Harry Potter books of library shelves
in elementary and middle schools. A 14-member panel of parents and teachers
later recommended a reversal of the superintendent’s orders, leaving
in place only his ban on reading the books aloud in the classroom.
In contrast to such restrictive examples, Lansing librarians believe
they deal with a more enlightened patronage. “I haven’t
heard any horror stories from librarians in the area,” Hamrick
said. The Delta Township library director plans to read from Edgar Lee
Masters’ “Spoon River Anthology.” Hamrick said that
the book written in 1916 was challenged because it was the first time
that American literature dealt with issues such as sex, depression and
suicide. “People didn’t like the idea that not everybody
in America was happy all the time.”
Bill
Castanier of Castanier Public Relations, a co-organizer of the Banned
Books Week in Lansing, pointed to the additional influence of subtle
censorship — or those books which never made it to the shelves.
“It’s all about how you select books. It’s pre-censorship.”
George Orwell, whose novel “Animal Farm” is 17th on the
Radcliffe Publishing Course’s Top 100 Novels of the 20th Century
banned books list, wrote in his preface: “The sinister fact about
literary censorship in England is that it is largely voluntary. Unpopular
ideas can be silenced, and inconvenient facts kept dark, without any
need for official ban.” The outcome is in part ensured by the
control of the press by “wealthy men who have every motive to
be dishonest on certain important topics.”
To give a contemporary example, in early September 2003, CNN’s
top war correspondent, Christiane Amanpour, admitted on CNBC that the
press muzzled itself during the Iraq invasion. Amanpour said CNN “was
intimidated” by the Bush administration and Fox News, which “put
a climate of fear and self-censorship.”
|
|