TUESDAY, March 11 — Technical difficulties marred U.S. Rep. Tom Barrett’s first telephone town hall last night.
The Charlotte Republican, whose district includes all of Ingham and Clinton counties and portions of Eaton, opened with a 20-minute speech discussing his work in Washington and addressing common questions his office has received. Afterward, he answered six questions from constituents. His office said more than 1,800 were on the call.
But many were unable to call in at all.
Hours before the meeting, Barrett’s official Facebook page posted that attendees who had signed up on Barrett’s website would receive an email with instructions to join the meeting. Those who called Barrett’s Lansing office were told they would receive a call between 7 p.m. and 7:10 p.m., the town hall’s scheduled starting time.
Many received neither.
“I didn’t receive a confirmation email nor a phone number to call,” said Polly Brainerd, who re-registered 30 minutes before the meeting after receiving no email.
“I was told I would get a call,” said Lansing resident Mike Malott. “No call came.”
This reporter was also not contacted after signing up on Barrett’s website. This reporter was only able to attend because the number was publicly posted on the Clinton County Republicans’ Facebook page at 6:57 p.m.
Because the sign-up form required attendees to disclose the topics of their questions in advance, some have speculated that liberal constituents were deliberately left out.
A representative for the Clinton County Republicans said he received the phone number directly from a member of Barrett’s staff shortly before the event.
The difficulties come on the heels of protesters demanding an in-person town hall with Barrett. Following protests at town halls across the country. House Speaker Mike Johnson recently encouraged Republican representatives not to hold in-person town halls.
The Livingston County Democrats and Indivisible Michigan 7, which organized separate protests for a town hall, were unsatisfied with the telephone format.
Tessa Paneth-Pollak, a coordinator for the Indivisible group, said not one member of the group she knows of received the phone number from Barrett’s office.
Judy Daubenmier, chair of the Livingston County Democrats, echoed this: “I have received comments by dozens and dozens of people saying they never received a number.”
A statement from Barrett’s D.C. office said the office is “aware of an error that prevented some folks from participating,” while also noting that “more than 26,000 outbound calls” were placed.
“We are investigating the cause to make sure it doesn’t happen again,” the statement said. “We will be hosting another event soon and will be sure to share the details when they are finalized.”
Those who were able to enter the call could join a queue to ask their questions. Despite reassurance from Barrett’s D.C. office that questions would not be screened, constituents who joined the queue received a call from a staff member who asked their name and question in advance.
A poll question — “Do you approve of the Department of Government Efficiency’s mission to streamline the federal government and reduce spending?” — received 70% “no” responses.
DOGE was a common thread. In his speech before the town hall, Barrett told constituents that DOGE “is only giving recommendations,” in response to concerns about presidential adviser Elon Musk’s power.
One constituent, George Allen of DeWitt, expressed a hope that DOGE would “use a scalpel and not an axe” in its layoffs at the Department of Veterans Affairs.
In response, Barrett said he had written a letter to the veterans affairs secretary, Douglas A. Collins, alleging that claims and appeals processes for veterans were “unacceptably long" and that he would work to fix this. He did not specifically address DOGE’s cuts.
One constituent, who identified herself as Eileen from Lansing, criticized Barrett’s support of a controversial budget proposal that Democrats allege will necessitate Medicaid and Medicare cuts.
Barrett denied that the bill would “require cuts to anything,” asserting that it “simply opened the process to see how we are going to move forward in this budget format.” He did acknowledge that eligibility criteria may be altered.
Daubenmier criticized Barrett’s responses, saying the town hall “was mainly a monologue.”
“He would take a comment and talk for 10 minutes,” she said.
While she still believed Barrett should hold an in-person town hall, Daubenmier said the telephone town hall was “an utter failure” on its own merits.
“If he was going to do it by telephone, he should have made sure that people who signed up received the number,” she said.
5 comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here
Support City Pulse - Donate Today!
NevinS
I signed up but obviously his team weeded out non-republicans for the call as I never received a email with instructions. At least even though he only took questions form republicans Walberg team called everyone who signed with a "select 1" to join the call. Barrett should take a clue from his other GOP members. but either way they all should take questions from all of us.
4 days ago Report this
oldvet
I signed up last week. I received NO email, NO phone number to call, and NO information on any further instructions on anything. I went on his Congressional website and it had a place to ask questions for the Town Hall. But that's it. Otherwise, NOTHING. I have sent 4 observations to his Congressional website. Two were acknowledged with emails that he received them and that they would be addressed with some sort of response from his staff. The other two there has been NO response from anyone period. How does he know who is and is not a republican? I am a Republican. He has taken an OATH to the Constitution at least 2 times. Once in the MILITARY and once as a Congressman. I now assume if you question why the US is now after 80 years supporting a Russian trained KGB War Criminal who murders people you are weeded out by his staff. I am interested to see if and when he has a real Town Hall.
4 days ago Report this
danieldekker
I have not been represented by Mr. Barrett before 2025, so I was willing to give him an opportunity to give a first impression. Monday's night first impression was a total disaster. This guy cannot even manage the technology of a telephone town hall. I did not receive any call in number or email in response to my registration. What an insult! I finally was able to connect 20 minutes in after I obtained the number from a slew of constituents who were complaining on his facebook page. There had been no townhall up to that point, just Barrett talking about himself. The subsequent questions were obviously screened as positive comments that made him look good. Instead of answering questions directly, he went on and on about himself. I have two items of advice for Mr. Barrett if he ever dreams of being re-elected: 1.) learn to listen more and talk less, and 2.) realize that 47% of your constituents did not vote for you - recognize their concerns or next time 52% will not be voting for you. .
4 days ago Report this
bematthe
This man spent months literally BEGGING for this job. We couldn't turn on our televisions or open our mailboxes without seeing him begging for this job. And in less than 2 months into it, he doesn't want to do it.
4 days ago Report this
Grey41
I registered. No call. No email. I call his office daily to have my voice heard, remind him of his oath to defend the constitution against all enemies foreign and domestic, as he follows suite with the project 2025 agenda, and the dismantling of our democracy and betraying the people, and assume they know my name and didn’t want me on the call. Barrett is a coward who won’t face the people. He will be primaried out, and his legacy will be that he was on the wrong side of history.
3 days ago Report this